A proposal to limit the program to five years, which passed by one vote, could undo a fragile Senate compromise on the full measure.
WASHINGTON -- A fragile compromise on immigration legislation could come unglued today after the Senate, by a margin of a single vote, limited the bill's guest worker program to five years.
The 49-48 vote for the amendment came shortly before the Senate recessed after midnight this morning. It was sponsored by Sen. Byron L. Dorgan (D-N.D.).
The original bill included a program that would have provided businesses 400,000 temporary foreign workers a year to do jobs that American workers would not fill. A subsequent amendment cut the program in half.
The amendment to limit the program to five years split California's two Democratic senators. Barbara Boxer, a co-sponsor of the amendment, voted for it, arguing that the guest workers would erode the wages of all low-income American workers. Dianne Feinstein, a sponsor of the original bill, voted against changing it.
Before the vote on the Dorgan amendment, supporters of the original bill defended it from attacks. They rebuffed one of the most serious challenges so far, defeating a measure that could have denied legalization to many illegal immigrants and moving the complicated legislation a step closer to passage in the Senate.
Senate Democratic leaders, fearing an erosion of support for the bill if debate drags on, are pushing for a final vote by early next week. The bill would then move to the House, where it is expected to face stiffer opposition.
"We've got one good chance to get this legislation passed," said Sen. Jon Kyl (R-Ariz.), a key supporter of the bill. "Now is the time."
The defeated amendment, proposed by Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas), would have permanently barred many convicted felons -- including sex offenders, gang members and repeat drunk drivers -- from qualifying to become legal permanent residents.
Supporters of the bill said, however, the amendment was written so loosely that it also would have barred those guilty of other felonies, such as violating deportation orders or using false identification documents. That, they said, would have applied to a huge number of illegal immigrants.
"We should not allow a path to legalization and citizenship for those who have openly defied our courts, lawful orders of our courts, and who have shown themselves as having no regard for the rule of law," Cornyn argued from the Senate floor before the vote. "What kind of citizens can we expect [of] these individuals who have been ordered deported, who have had their day in court and who simply defied that court order by going on the lam and melting into the American landscape?"
But Sen. Edward M. Kennedy (D-Mass.), the primary Democratic sponsor of the legislation, accused Cornyn of classifying "an array of common, garden-variety immigration offenses as crimes that would make them ineligible for the program."
"The Cornyn amendment that says if you have been ordered out of the country by immigration authorities, but if you failed to leave or you came back, you're ineligible," Kennedy said on the Senate floor. "Cornyn says that if you have used false identification, you may be found inadmissible and may be deported. But in our broken system, the people that have wanted to work face the reality of where we are today."
Senators defeated the Cornyn amendment 51 to 46, with Feinstein and Boxer voting against it.
"We're still on track," Feinstein, a key member of the bipartisan group that drafted the proposal, said after the vote.
The chamber adopted by a 66-32 vote a measure proposed by Kennedy that included many of the same provisions against violent felons but allowed more discretion for judges in the case of immigration-related offenses. Both California senators supported the Kennedy version.
"What we are doing with this amendment is keeping the enforcement without killing the bill," said Sen. Charles E. Schumer (D-N.Y.).
At the heart of the immigration proposal is an agreement reached by a bipartisan group of senators to allow most of the estimated 12 million illegal immigrants already in the country to apply for legalization in return for building an immigration system that would give greater priority to education and economic need than family reunification.
The legislation splits both Democrats and Republicans, making the debate and amendment process more unpredictable than usual.
"The more you try to change it, the more you risk losing it," Sen. Pete V. Domenici (R-N.M.), who supports the bill, said on the Senate floor. He pleaded with Republicans to limit their proposed amendments, and with Democrats to permit at least enough time for debate to give Republicans a sense that the deliberations have been fair.
To protect the bill's central agreement, senators also defeated, on a procedural vote, an amendment that would have increased the number of visas available for family members now waiting for green cards in an effort to clear the backlog in applications.
Kyl raised budgetary objections to the amendment, proposed by Sen. Robert Menendez (D-N.J.), and 60 votes were needed to waive the objection. A vote on the waiver failed 53 to 44; Feinstein and Boxer both voted for it. A secondary amendment by Kyl that would permit more applications to be considered but would not increase the number of visas issued was passed on a party line vote of 51 to 45, with both California senators voting against it.
"This is a fig leaf for those who voted against" the last amendment, Menendez said, urging colleagues to defeat Kyl's version. "It does nothing for family reunification."
Another amendment, which passed 57 to 39, would waive the confidentiality of applications submitted by illegal immigrants who are denied legal status, making the information available to law enforcement.
Behind the scenes, party leaders and members of the bipartisan group of senators who negotiated the deal -- known as the "grand bargain" -- discussed an agreement over how much longer to debate and how many more amendments to consider.
"The majority leader is controlling this debate. The train is moving down the track and very few amendments are being considered," a leading opponent of the bill, Sen. Jeff Sessions (R-Ala.), said as he attempted to introduce more amendments.
Sessions told reporters that opponents want to continue the debate because the longer it goes on, the more support for the legislation slips away. "I think that has sort of been the case," Sessions said. "I don't know how many votes are changing [but senators] are not happy with the way things are going."
Source : www.latimes.com
WASHINGTON -- A fragile compromise on immigration legislation could come unglued today after the Senate, by a margin of a single vote, limited the bill's guest worker program to five years.
The 49-48 vote for the amendment came shortly before the Senate recessed after midnight this morning. It was sponsored by Sen. Byron L. Dorgan (D-N.D.).
The original bill included a program that would have provided businesses 400,000 temporary foreign workers a year to do jobs that American workers would not fill. A subsequent amendment cut the program in half.
The amendment to limit the program to five years split California's two Democratic senators. Barbara Boxer, a co-sponsor of the amendment, voted for it, arguing that the guest workers would erode the wages of all low-income American workers. Dianne Feinstein, a sponsor of the original bill, voted against changing it.
Before the vote on the Dorgan amendment, supporters of the original bill defended it from attacks. They rebuffed one of the most serious challenges so far, defeating a measure that could have denied legalization to many illegal immigrants and moving the complicated legislation a step closer to passage in the Senate.
Senate Democratic leaders, fearing an erosion of support for the bill if debate drags on, are pushing for a final vote by early next week. The bill would then move to the House, where it is expected to face stiffer opposition.
"We've got one good chance to get this legislation passed," said Sen. Jon Kyl (R-Ariz.), a key supporter of the bill. "Now is the time."
The defeated amendment, proposed by Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas), would have permanently barred many convicted felons -- including sex offenders, gang members and repeat drunk drivers -- from qualifying to become legal permanent residents.
Supporters of the bill said, however, the amendment was written so loosely that it also would have barred those guilty of other felonies, such as violating deportation orders or using false identification documents. That, they said, would have applied to a huge number of illegal immigrants.
"We should not allow a path to legalization and citizenship for those who have openly defied our courts, lawful orders of our courts, and who have shown themselves as having no regard for the rule of law," Cornyn argued from the Senate floor before the vote. "What kind of citizens can we expect [of] these individuals who have been ordered deported, who have had their day in court and who simply defied that court order by going on the lam and melting into the American landscape?"
But Sen. Edward M. Kennedy (D-Mass.), the primary Democratic sponsor of the legislation, accused Cornyn of classifying "an array of common, garden-variety immigration offenses as crimes that would make them ineligible for the program."
"The Cornyn amendment that says if you have been ordered out of the country by immigration authorities, but if you failed to leave or you came back, you're ineligible," Kennedy said on the Senate floor. "Cornyn says that if you have used false identification, you may be found inadmissible and may be deported. But in our broken system, the people that have wanted to work face the reality of where we are today."
Senators defeated the Cornyn amendment 51 to 46, with Feinstein and Boxer voting against it.
"We're still on track," Feinstein, a key member of the bipartisan group that drafted the proposal, said after the vote.
The chamber adopted by a 66-32 vote a measure proposed by Kennedy that included many of the same provisions against violent felons but allowed more discretion for judges in the case of immigration-related offenses. Both California senators supported the Kennedy version.
"What we are doing with this amendment is keeping the enforcement without killing the bill," said Sen. Charles E. Schumer (D-N.Y.).
At the heart of the immigration proposal is an agreement reached by a bipartisan group of senators to allow most of the estimated 12 million illegal immigrants already in the country to apply for legalization in return for building an immigration system that would give greater priority to education and economic need than family reunification.
The legislation splits both Democrats and Republicans, making the debate and amendment process more unpredictable than usual.
"The more you try to change it, the more you risk losing it," Sen. Pete V. Domenici (R-N.M.), who supports the bill, said on the Senate floor. He pleaded with Republicans to limit their proposed amendments, and with Democrats to permit at least enough time for debate to give Republicans a sense that the deliberations have been fair.
To protect the bill's central agreement, senators also defeated, on a procedural vote, an amendment that would have increased the number of visas available for family members now waiting for green cards in an effort to clear the backlog in applications.
Kyl raised budgetary objections to the amendment, proposed by Sen. Robert Menendez (D-N.J.), and 60 votes were needed to waive the objection. A vote on the waiver failed 53 to 44; Feinstein and Boxer both voted for it. A secondary amendment by Kyl that would permit more applications to be considered but would not increase the number of visas issued was passed on a party line vote of 51 to 45, with both California senators voting against it.
"This is a fig leaf for those who voted against" the last amendment, Menendez said, urging colleagues to defeat Kyl's version. "It does nothing for family reunification."
Another amendment, which passed 57 to 39, would waive the confidentiality of applications submitted by illegal immigrants who are denied legal status, making the information available to law enforcement.
Behind the scenes, party leaders and members of the bipartisan group of senators who negotiated the deal -- known as the "grand bargain" -- discussed an agreement over how much longer to debate and how many more amendments to consider.
"The majority leader is controlling this debate. The train is moving down the track and very few amendments are being considered," a leading opponent of the bill, Sen. Jeff Sessions (R-Ala.), said as he attempted to introduce more amendments.
Sessions told reporters that opponents want to continue the debate because the longer it goes on, the more support for the legislation slips away. "I think that has sort of been the case," Sessions said. "I don't know how many votes are changing [but senators] are not happy with the way things are going."
Source : www.latimes.com
184 comments:
buy ativan online ativan side effects/ringing in the ears - ativan side effects alzheimer's
buy tramadol without prescriptions tramadol dosage vicodin - can buy tramadol usa
tramadol overnight shipping tramadol buy cheap - tramadol 50 mg order online
cheap klonopin online klonopin dosage length - klonopin side effects kids
buy tramadol online high dose of tramadol - maximum dosage tramadol 24 hours
buy tramadol online buy tramadol 24x7 - ultram online legal
buy tramadol overnight shipping can someone overdose tramadol - tramadol 50 mg side effects for dogs
clonazepam online buy cheap clonazepam online - high dose of klonopin
buy tramadol best site order tramadol - buy tramadol with cod delivery
purchase tramadol tramadol hcl 100 mg er tablets - buy tramadol cod personal check
lorazepam 1mg ativan side effects heart - side effects of ativan 0.5mg
cheap tramadol online tramadol for dogs sleepy - tramadol high forum
generic ambien ambien and alcohol abuse - ambien rx sleeping pill
buy carisoprodol online buy soma us pharmacy - soma 250 drug interactions
buy tramadol online reviews get tramadol online no prescription - buy tramadol us pharmacy
buy tramadol tramadol hcl 50mg street value - tramadol for dogs cancer
buy tramadol online tramadol online international - tramadol hcl nsaid
tramadol no rx tramadol online no prescription overnight delivery - tramadol dosage 15 lb dog
ambien 5 problems with ambien sleep medication - ambien cr 6.25 mg tablet
lorazepam 1mg ativan 20mg - need to buy ativan
carisoprodol without prescription buy soma georgia - soma 50
ambien for sale ambien tablets online - ambien drug food interactions
generic ativan ativan uses and dosages - 4mg ativan high
buy generic klonopin klonopin dosage pediatric - klonopin 2mg overnight
soma online soma online booking - who carries soma bras
buy klonopin online side effects of klonopin weight gain - 2mg klonopin withdrawal
buy tramadol online without a prescription tramadol 400 mg dose - order tramadol online cod
tramadol online buy ultramon - tramadol hcl with alcohol
generic carisoprodol soma 700 mg - soma devlet hastanesi online randevu alma
cheapest ativan ativan recreational dose - lorazepam ativan online
tramadol online buy tramadol tablets - normal dosage tramadol humans
online soma soma san diego events - soma online no prescription overnight
ambien zolpidem buy ambien online us pharmacy - 10mg ambien street price
tramadol online tramadol 37.5-325 - order tramadol online uk
viagra online viagra overnight - viagra by mail
ambien online where to buy ambien cr - ambien cost street
buy tramadol tramadol high triglycerides - buy tramadol dogs
cheap tramadol online buy tramadol without prescriptions - tramadol 50 mg medicine
buy tramadol online reviews tramadol 50 mg snort - order tramadol with saturday delivery
viagra no prescription overnight delivery order generic viagra online overnight - order viagra cheap
clonazepam medication what does 2mg klonopin look like - buy brand klonopin online
order viagra online without a prescription viagra online store india - buy viagra online with paypal
order viagra online without a prescription how to order viagra online in india - viagra+buy+pharmacy
klonopin pills buy cheap clonazepam no prescription - klonopin hydrocodone
buy ambien online ambien cr nightmares - ambien side effects death
buy tramadol saturday delivery cheap tramadol no prescription - buy tramadol online no prescription overnight
buy soma online soma van ness - soma 12 panel drug screen
buy viagra online legally cheapest order pharmacy viagra - legal purchase viagra
buy viagra online reviews viagra mastercard online pharmacy - buy viagra 500mg
viagra online viagra for women meaning - men's health viagra online
purchase soma buy soma online no prescription - buy soma louisiana
viagra online no prescriptions cheap viagra adelaide - viagra online new york
soma generic drug schedule of soma - information on soma medication
buy viagra for women best place buy generic viagra online - viagra online shop
order viagra usa generic viagra lowest price - viagra for women uk sales
mail order viagra online viagra for women in uk - buy real viagra online
cialis online cialis tv commercial actors - cialis лекарство
buy tramadol online tramadol withdrawal brain zaps - suboxone tramadol high
buy viagra cheap cheap viagra uk paypal - online viagra sales canada
buy cheap viagra safe purchase viagra online - viagra online thailand
order tramadol online tramadol ketorolaco - tramadol hcl 10 mg
propecia pharmacy propecia update - buy propecia dubai
buy tramadol without rx what's the tramadol high like - order+tramadol+online+in+florida
buy tramadol without a script tramadol online pharmacy usa - tramadol withdrawal in infants
order finasteride propecia bodybuilding - generic propecia just effective
buy cialis viagra cialis online pharmacy us - cialis online 2.5mg
buy tramadol online buy tramadol online saturday delivery - buy tramadol online with american express
generic tramadol online tramadol for dogs+urination - buy tramadol online in usa
order tramadol online overnight tramadol overdose dosage - cheap generic tramadol
buy tramadol cod online tramadol overdose side effects - tramadol 93 58 high
cheap viagra 100mg buy viagra pills - does generic viagra work yahoo
buy retin-a buy retin a micro gel no prescription - buy retin a .1 online
buy viagra without prescriptions buy viagra online pharmacy - viagra dosage for young men
generic propecia online generic propecia sunrise - propecia new study
buy retin-a buy retin 0.05 - retin a cream drugstore
propecia online can you buy propecia in the uk - propecia side effects finasteride
buy retin-a difference between retin a gel and cream - buy retin a acne treatment
cheap tramadol buy ultram - buy tramadol from uk
best buy tramadol tramadol 200mg dosage - buy tramadol online eu
tramadol 50mg tramadol 800mg ibuprofen - cheap 100mg tramadol
buy tramadol tramadol with acetaminophen dosage - tramadol online bluebook
buy propecia online can you buy propecia in boots - propecia pregnancy
tramadol online tramadol addiction helpline - buy tramadol 200
buy tramadol tramadol cod - order tramadol online mastercard
buy retin-a online buy retin a in melbourne - buy retin a online in usa
tramadol no prescription buy tramadol online cod no prescription - tramadol 50 mg order online
buy tramadol online cheap ultram tramadol hci tablets - buy tramadol online mastercard overnight
tramadol 50mg is it legal to get tramadol online - tramadol addiction withdrawal
cheap tramadol tramadol cost - tramadol 50mg nhs
buy retin-a retin a cream indication - retin a side effects treatment
buy tramadol tramadol purchase online uk - order tramadol online no prescription
buy tramadol where to buy ultram online - buy tramadol in uk
legal buy tramadol online buy tramadol c.o.d saturday delivery - tramadol 50 mg a narcotic
buy retin-a online retin a cream 0.25 - retin a gel apply
tramadol 50 mg tramadol hcl 50 mg get you high - tramadol 100mg usa
tramadol online safe place order tramadol online - 100mg of tramadol high
tramadol 100mg tramadol order online tramadol 50mg - generic tramadol
buy tramadol buy tramadol pay with mastercard - tramadol 50mg how much
discount viagra viagra erection - buy viagra mumbai
generic cialis cialis xanax - cialis 800 black
buy viagra online cheap generic viagra next day delivery - viagra 100mg cost
tadalafil tablets cheap cialis pills - cialis user reviews
buy tramadol buy tramadol australia - tramadol zolpidem
generic cialis cheap cialis next day delivery - can you buy cialis online in canada
buy cialis online no prescription generic cialis reviews - should you buy cialis online
buy tramadol buy tramadol online us pharmacy - buy tramadol personal check
buy tramadol buy tramadol online with visa - tramadol dosage for pain
buy cialis online cialis 40 mg - cialis online+toronto
viagra online without prescription how to buy viagra online without - buy viagra online cheap us
buy cialis buy cialis reviews - safe buy cialis online canada
viagra online buy viagra qatar - viagra buy online cheap
buy viagra where to buy viagra online us - online viagra sales us
buy cialis cialis price nz - order real cialis online
cheap viagra online where to buy viagra online forum - purchase viagra with mastercard
generic viagra online cheap viagra next day delivery us - cheap generic viagra online pharmacy
generic cialis http://www.cialis-online-shop.com - cialis online overnight
buy soma online buy somatropin from china - generic soma for sale
generic cialis can you buy cialis over the counter in canada - buy cheap generic cialis online
buy cialis cialis stories - cialis online order
generic cialis generic cialis in usa - generic cialis mjy.blogspot.com
buy cialis cialis 5 mg online kaufen - cheapest cialis online uk
cialis price cialis generic usa - cialis daily sale
viagra online viagra dosage difference - cheap viagra online 100mg
generic cialis can you buy cialis online with no prescription - cialis everyday price
buy cialis buy genuine cialis online - order cialis online overnight
generic cialis cialis upset stomach - buy real cialis cheap
buy tramadol online buy tramadol usa next day delivery - tramadol 50mg for dogs
viagra online cheap viagra super - generic viagra pictures
order soma online soma san diego bring me horizon - buy soma georgia
buy soma online buy soma online us - discount for soma
viagra online viagra like drugs - buy generic viagra no prescription
viagra no prescription mail order viagra in the u.k - buy viagra online cheap us
buy soma online cost cab sfo soma - tramadol soma online
buy soma online soma tires - what is soma 350 mg for
viagra online order viagra online next-day - where can i buy viagra and for how much
buy soma online somo 655 hard reset - watson brand soma online
buy soma buy somatropin online - buy soma online ship texas
buy soma online klonopin soma drug interaction - buy soma cod overnight
buy soma soma san diego 21 - order soma in georgia
buy soma online buy generic soma - soma bras comfortable
cheap soma soma 84 - soma buy online no prescription
buy soma online soma motel for sale oregon - soma health club costs
soma for sale soma san diego theater - soma online coupon codes
buy retin-a retin a gel how does it work - buy retin a usa online
buy soma online soma bras intimates - buy soma online texas
buy retin a retin a micro website - retin a micro itchy skin
order cialis online cialis 20 mg price comparison - buy cialis fda
buy tramadol tramadol 100mg no prescription - tramadol 85 93
buy tramadol online where to buy ultram online - buy tramadol overnight shipping
tramadol online buy tramadol online tennessee - tramadol online no prescription overnight
buy tramadol online buy ultram tramadol online - how to buy tramadol online overnight
buy retin a micro retin a gel vs cream - retin-a gel concentrations
buy tramadol no rx buy tramadol online overnight - tramadol hydrochloride high
can you buy tramadol online legally tramadol 50 mg for migraine - buy generic tramadol online
buy tramadol best site purchase tramadol - tramadol 100 er
retin a skin retin a 0.01 gel para que sirve - buy retin a 0.025 cream
tramadol no rx tramadol dosage for dogs by weight - tramadol kick in time
tramadol 50 mg buy tramadol online no prescription usa - tramadol buy online no prescription mastercard
buy tramadol online mastercard overnight ultram er online - buy tramadol money order
buy tramadol rx tramadol high blood pressure - tramadol hcl 50mg get you high
buy retin a retin-a micro 0.1 gel coupon - retin a micro moisturizer
buy tramadol without prescriptions ultram 50 mg tablets - buy tramadol online us pharmacy
cheap tramadol tramadol hcl online pharmacy - kind high tramadol
tramadol overnight shipping tramadol hcl online - tramadol hcl online
cheap tramadol no prescription buy tramadol online australia no prescription - buy tramadol 100mg online
buy tramadol cod overnight tramadol 50 mg veterinary use - tramadol online no prescription uk
buy tramadol tramadol for dogs 100mg - can you order tramadol online
tramadol no rx tramadol premature ejaculation - generic tramadol no prescription overnight
tramadol online buy tramadol overnight shipping - tramadol 50mg vs lortab
tramadol online pharmacy buy tramadol cod overnight delivery - tramadol extended release 200 mg
tramadol online tramadol with high blood pressure - tramadol high mg
buy carisoprodol carisoprodol 350 mg contraindications - carisoprodol 350 mg drug test
tramadol online tramadol order online tramadol 50mg - order tramadol online no prescription
cialis online usa cialis reviews men - can you buy cialis in dubai
tadalafil online cheap cialis and viagra - cialis back pain
generic cialis best buy cialis online - cialis 40 mg
cialis online buy generic cialis us - buy cialis new zealand
xanax online high off xanax xr - xanax xanax cheap pharmacy online
buy tramadol online no prescription overnight 3 tramadol high - cheap tramadol online no prescription
http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#96430 buy tramadol online overnight - cheap tramadol cod free fedex
buy klonopin online generic klonopin side effects - pink generic klonopin
http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#59473 tramadol no prescription next day delivery - buy tramadol in egypt
learn how to buy tramdadol tramadol hcl taken with tylenol - tramadol hydrochloride 50 mg get high
klonopin online generic klonopin vs brand - highest dosage klonopin
Post a Comment